Western Education: Memory Test vs Intelligence

By: Faizat Hamzat
According to Britannica, ‘human intelligence is a mental quality that consists of the abilities to learn from experience, adapt to new situations, understand and handle abstract concepts, and use knowledge to manipulate one’s environment.’ And according to Samareducation, ‘Intelligence is the ability to acquire and apply knowledge. Intelligence is defined as a mental capability that involves the ability to reason, to plan, to solve problems, to think abstractly, to comprehend complex ideas, to learn quickly and to learn from experience.’
From these definitions of intelligence, one can connote that it is the ability to acquire knowledge and being able to apply it to solve problems.
Taking a critical glance at our educational system, one will notice that we have mistaken something else entirely for ‘intelligence’. At the end of every term, semester or session, we have top students who are tagged as being ‘intelligent’ after an examination has taken place to assess the students. The ones able to achieve a high score are awarded a prize and the title of being ‘intelligent’, while the others who are not able to attain a high score are tagged otherwise.
But what we tag as intelligence is more of a memory test than what should be intelligence. Before exams, you see students trying their best to memorize what has been taught in class for the sake of the examination. But has the educational system ever questioned if the students can recall what they memorized after the examination? Has the educational system been able to know if these students have been able to apply what they were taught in class? It is the same cycle for most students: memorize or cram, pour and forget, without implementing.
According to a survey reported by Nairametrics, ‘75% of employers say colleges are not properly preparing students for the workforce. While 91% of employers want graduates to be able to solve practical problems, only 40% of graduates report receiving this kind of training during their education.’ This survey explains that most graduates lack problem-solving skills (an element of being intelligent) in the labour force. This is why you will see a first-class graduate struggling to get employed even with an excellent certificate. You will almost wonder, where did it go wrong?
In the latest UCJUI Campulse magazine, an interview was conducted with Professor Saheed Aderinto, Professor of History and African Diaspora Studies at Florida International University. There he stated that: ‘‘I have a nephew in UI who lives in my house behind the U.I. campus. His CGPA is 2:2. The reason he is on 2:2 is because when he writes he is using his own words to write and then the student who get his first class or a 2:1 maybe a student who knows how to cram. It is like in some fields the only way to get a 2:1 is to be able to cram and pour it back. This kid is used to using his own language and because he’s using his own language to write, there is a lot of typographic errors, stylistic errors and so that is why his grade is low. There’s another kid who is not going to come to class and is just going to come a day before the end of the class. He is going to cram everything and is going to make a 2:1.’’
His nephew represents something different from cramming, he probably understands that one factor to build himself is based on his ability to express himself in his own words. That will build strong research and writing skills. Yet, by him having a low grade, reveals that the educational system supports memorization, rather than understanding. The ones with probably 2:1 or first-class may represent credit to the memory test. As they mostly rely on cram, pour and forget systems.
One will see school dropouts or some with average results, some tagged as unintelligent, doing well outside Western education. Why? This is because a great part of our educational system lacks problem-solving skills, unlike manual skills out there. Skills like carpentry, bricklaying, fashion designing and others are practicable and problem-solving. These skills portray what intelligence should be. This is because these skills are dynamic and complex; for a person to learn and apply them is intelligence indeed. Our educational system only gives praise to memory capacity.
Bill Gates, for example, is a dropout of Harvard University and started Microsoft. The same with Mark Zuckerberg, who also dropped out of Harvard University to start Facebook. Steve Jobs started Apple after dropping out of Reed College. Cosmas Maduka, Innocent Ifediaso Chukwuma and many others are school dropouts, yet they built massive success outside formal education with problem-solving skills. Their intelligence, including the ability to apply knowledge and solve problems, has given them success, not necessarily a degree.
However, Intelligence cannot be totally independent from memorization. It is only when a student remembers what he had been taught or what skill he had acquired that he will be able to implement it. Still, it should be known that, even though memorization is an essential attribute of intelligence, intelligence is still beyond memory and also includes the ability to apply knowledge. What is the use of a student who memorizes twenty philosophical quotes but cannot implement one? An educational system that encourages practical knowledge, problem-solving skills, realistic theories and also discourages the idea of ‘cramming’ should be introduced in formal learning. With that, a student with an outstanding degree will be able to go out there and make a living with all he has learned.
Image credit: Pediaa.com

This lecture was quite helpful
It is clear nowadays, that academic institutions aren’t based on realistic teaching or impacting learners with the right process for applying knowledge. They just teach , I’m not sure they care if those they’re teaching understand what they’re learning, and exactly how to use that knowledge in the real world.