AFCON 2025: Do Laws Matters More than the Game?

By Joshua Oyetoro
Fifty-eight days after Senegal was crowned champions of the 2025 AFCON tournament on the pitch, CAF decided to re-write a seemingly perfect ending of the tournament, by stripping them of glory and handing the title to Morocco from the boardroom.
Traditionally, the outcome of every football match is decided on the pitch at the blast of the referee’s final whistle. But that was not the case for the AFCON 2025 final that was played at the Prince Moulay Abdullah Stadium in Rabat, Morrocco. What was meant to be the crowning moment of African football, instead, has unraveled into a spectacle of protests, controversies, and legal maneuvering.
When Senegal walked off the pitch in the heat of the final, it was more than just a reaction to a referee’s call that seemed unfair to them, rather, it was a decision that would ultimately cost them the title. And when CAF in its ruling on the 17th March 2026, awarded the trophy to Morocco, that signaled the beginning of a debate that has since gripped the footballing world.
In the aftermath of the ruling, officials within the Federation Royale Marocaine de Football (Moroccan Football Federation), pointed to the need to uphold the integrity of the competition, insisting that the laws governing the game must be respected regardless of circumstance. Fairs.
On the other hand, the Senegalese Football Federation rejected the decision outrightly, describing it as unjust and confirming plans to challenge the ruling at the court of Arbitration for Sports.Well alright.
However, set against these competing claims, one uncomfortable truth remains clear: no one involved is without fault and is innocent.
…The Law is clear; But is Justice?
CAF’s ruling firmly rested on its regulations, particularly provisions that deal with match abandonment and refusal to continue play under these rules. Senegal’s decision to leave the pitch while the game was still in progress constituted a clear violation of that rule.
As the CAF Appeal Board noted, “the conduct of the Senegal team falls within the scope of Article 82 and 84,” thereby triggering the disciplinary consequences attached to such actions.
The Senegalese team might have even argued that Articles 82 and 84 bore vague interpretations, but the provisions are in fact, clear. They state that “if for any REASON WHATSOEVER, a team refuses to play or leaves the ground (field of play)… it shall be considered the loser of that game.”
From a strictly legal standpoint, CAF’s decision is defensible. Football, like any regulated competition, depends on adherence to established rules. Once a team takes matters into its own hands and abandons play, it undermines the authority of the referee and the integrity of the competition itself. Bar emotions, the law is the law. And by the law, Senegal crossed the line.
Yet, this is only one side of the argument.Football has long been governed by another equally fundamental principle: the authority of the referee. Under the Laws of the Game as set by the International Football Association Board, the referee is the final arbiter of events on the pitch, with full power to control the match and determine its outcome in real time.
In the AFCON final, despite the disruption caused by Senegal’s walk-off, the referee allowed play to resume, the match was completed, and a result was produced on the pitch.
This raises a difficult question: if the referee permitted the game to reach its natural conclusion, should that outcome be overturned after the fact?
CAF’s decision, though grounded in its regulatory framework, effectively set aside the authority exercised on the field in favour of administrative enforcement; an action that transformed the outcome from one decided through play, into one determined through procedure.
And it is within this tension that the controversy truly lies and not merely in what the rules say, but in how they are applied when the authority of the referee and the authority of the rulebook collide.
Moving on, while it is agreed that Senegal was found guilty within the laws of the game, Morocco’s position also raises a different kind of question that borders on ethics and sporting integrity.
In the aftermath of the decision, narratives emerged from Moroccan quarters about upholding the “tenets of the competition’s rules.” On the surface, it is a compelling stance. But when placed against the backdrop of events during the match, it becomes, at best, ironic, and at worst, deeply contradictory.
Reports of ball-boys interfering with the flow of the game, alongside other questionable match-day occurrences, led CAF itself to sanction the Moroccan federation. These events were not just minor infractions, they were actions that chipped away at the very fairness that Morocco now claim to defend.
To speak of upholding the integrity of the competition while being implicated in a conduct that undermines it, is quite frankly, laughable.
A host nation must carry a responsibility that extends beyond logistics. It is the custodian of fairness, neutrality, and respect for the game. On that front, Morocco did not fully measure up.
…A Contest of Arguments, Not Football
What this situation ultimately reveals is a competition that was decided less by footballing brilliance and but procedural advantage.
Senegal may have lost the match by abandoning the pitch, but Morocco did not exactly win it in the spirit of the game. Instead, what we witnessed was a shift from a contest in skill to a contest of legal arguments. In this African Cup of Nations, victory was not sealed by a decisive goal, but by who could better argue their case effectively within the CAF regulatory framework. No one is a saint, rather, we see participants in a system where the sharpest arguments often prevails over the fairest outcome on the field of play.
Unsurprisingly, the Senegal Football Federation has moved to challenge the ruling, with plans to escalate the matter to the FIFA and potentially the court of Arbitration for Sports.
This next phase will test not just the legality of CAF’s decision, but its legitimacy in the eyes of the global football community. And make no mistake: the world is watching.
Not with admiration, but with skepticism. Not in celebration, but with what can only be described as hands wrapped around bowls of popcorns, and glee on their faces.
…A Tournament That Has Lost Its Soul
For all its history and prestige, the AFCON is meant to be a celebration of African football, its talent, its passion, and its identity.
This edition, however, tells a different story. Instead of goals and glory, it has rather delivered controversies and courtroom drama, rather than elevate the sport, it has exposed its vulnerabilities of administrative inconsistencies, questionable conduct, and a fragile sense of fairness.
Call it fighting for justice. Call it enforcing the rules. Whatever name it goes by, the result remains the same: the essence of football has been lost in the noise of legal drama.
At its core, football is supposed to be decided on the pitch by moments of brilliance, not moments of breakdown and court ruling.
Yet, AFCON 2025 will be remembered not for the beauty of the game but for the chaos that overshadowed it.
In the end, Senegal broke the rules. Morocco too has bent the spirit of the game. CAF has enforced the law.
And somewhere in between, African football took a hit it did not deserve.
Because when the game becomes secondary to the drama, everyone losses.
And this is a sad reflection of what parts of the sport have become on the African continent.
