When Does Thinking Stop Being Healthy?
by Faizat Hamzat
Overthinking may seem funny and harmless. But have you ever wondered when it stops being funny?
Have you ever woken up and started analysing a conversation you had the day before? Wondered whether your friend’s laughter was actually mockery? Or replayed an embarrassing moment from years ago and found yourself cringing all over again? Or perhaps your thoughts keep running long after you have gone to bed, making it difficult to sleep.
What you are experiencing may be overthinking, which can overlap with the psychological concept of rumination, where a person repeatedly focuses on negative thoughts, experiences or past events. But when does ordinary thinking or reflection become unhealthy?
Overthinking does not necessarily have to be about past events. It can also involve over analysing the future, worrying about what is yet to come.
In a genuinely heartbreaking or hurtful situation, overthinkers may not feel entirely surprised. However, they can still feel disappointed because they may have already considered the possibility of it happening. Some may describe this as “preparing for the worst.” For many people who struggle with overthinking, expecting negative outcomes can become a pattern that makes it difficult to focus on more positive possibilities.
While overthinking is not recognised as a mental illness itself, persistent overthinking and rumination can occur alongside mental health conditions such as anxiety and depression.
Recognising When You Overthink
A lot of people mistake overthinking for reflection or problem solving. However, the three situations are clearly distinguishable. For instance, when you have an exam in a week you are yet to prepare for, and you say, “I will read chapter one today, practise questions related to it, and take another topic tomorrow,” you have practised problem solving. In problem-solving situations, you identify a problem, ‘think’ about it and drive towards a conclusion.
Meanwhile, reflection is, “I did not do well in the last exam because I started preparing the night before. I need to change that and start preparing now.” It is a careful thought you have concerning past events in order to identify your mistakes and work on them if possible.
Overthinking, on its own, will often drive towards ‘what ifs’; brooding over spilt milk and possible or impossible situations that are tainted with negativity. It borders on “What if I fail?” or “What if the questions are difficult?” without reflecting on why that may happen or finding a solution to prevent it from happening.
In essence, overthinking can be described as repeatedly thinking or worrying about past or future events in an unhealthy way, without a resolution, which affects oneself, productivity and relationships with people.
Cleveland Clinic (2022) describes overthinking as “worrying that jumps from one topic to the next, thinking of the worst-case scenario, struggling to make decisions, including second-guessing, trouble concentrating, feeling on edge and seeking repeated reassurance from others.”
Why do People Overthink?
People overthink for different reasons. Some overthink to control anxiety, that is, when they are anxious about something coming next, they resort to overthinking in order to predict what may happen or prepare themselves for what is likely to happen. Most times, this prediction is not always positive, thereby leading to emotional stress.
Another cause of overthinking is shame. A recurrence of a past embarrassing event or something they had said earlier can trigger overthinking.
Also, indecisiveness is another leading cause of overthinking. Of course, reflecting on the pros and cons of a decision can prevent risks, but repeatedly going over it, especially without a resolution or taking the next action, will result in overthinking.
Overthinking can occur when your environment is quiet, probably when you are alone or less busy for a period. Although, for some people, the case may be a few moments before drifting into sleep. As they lay down and their mind drifts back to past events or what they are anxious about, they may find it hard to sleep.
As stated before, overthinking has a negative effect on oneself, productivity and relationships with people.
Effects of Overthinking
One of the leading effects of overthinking is psychological stress. The more you keep repeating your negative ‘what ifs,’ the more the anxiety.
Also, it may lead to headaches or other physical symptoms depending on the situation and the level of distress involved. Guilt and nausea may also occur alongside overthinking, particularly when an embarrassing or distressing moment reoccurs repeatedly.
More so, overthinking can cause distractions, making focusing and decision-making difficult.
Overall, overthinking can prevent people from being productive. Continuously going over a decision or being anxious over it can trap you in your fear without making a meaningful decision.
The Inter/Intra-personal Effects of Overthinking
Overthinking can cause a lot of issues when it comes to relationships. One of these is doubt. It makes you doubt a gesture of a friend, doubt a laughter as mockery and a compliment as an insult. With doubt, your attitude towards a person you were once closer with will gradually change, that is, if you have had issues with them in the past. And this is where communication seeps in. You ask questions about people’s reactions if you are unclear so you don’t give yourself unnecessary headaches by overthinking it thereafter. More importantly, if not careful, overthinking may plant a seed of distrust in you and may disrupt your relationships with your loved ones.
Further, it can also have a negative effect on your intrapersonal relationship, a relationship with your own self. It makes you doubt your abilities and aspirations, and you may seem to yourself as one that is not enough for the task. This may lead to low self-esteem. You may even start comparing yourself to others.
Overthinking is not always a bad thing, but most of the time, it can prove to be bad. It may lead to making the best decisions and taking the best actions too. But it becomes unhealthy when it is having a negative impact on you.
How to Handle Overthinking
While overthinking cannot be possibly cured, it can be controlled. For some people, being alone or less busy can serve as the best time for overthinking to tap in. This can be avoided by getting a healthy distraction. You can read books, listen to songs, watch a movie or simply take a stroll. Finding someone to talk to can also help distract you.
You can also try challenging your thoughts. Ask yourself how that past event matters now or if there is a lesson to learn from it that will help in the future. If it is the future or a coming decision you are anxious about, instead of the ‘what ifs,’ challenge your mind. Why do I think that can happen? How do I prevent it? What action should I take to prevent it?
If these thoughts involve your relationship with others, you may try challenging them indirectly or in a friendly way to avoid conflict. And if you are not the type that challenges people, adopting the practice of talking to loved ones about issues that bother you proves effective most times instead of keeping it all to yourself.
Additionally, learning to meditate or listening to meditation or calming audios can help control overthinking.
And if overthinking is associated with sleeplessness for you, with reference to Gardiner et al. (2023), avoid taking heavy meals, caffeine or energy drinks late in the day, as this can increase your restlessness at night.
When overthinking comes with doubts and difficulty in decision making, you can think about your achievements and breakthroughs, even the tiniest ones. Think about the people you have once made proud. And also, embrace your fears rather than allowing them to conquer you.
If you experience excessive overthinking with possible effects, it is advisable to seek therapy or a related specialist.
Overall, thinking is always important and useful, but repetitive thinking without taking action is the problem. So, the goal is not to stop thinking, it is to control repetitive thoughts that can have negative effects on one’s psychological, physical and social persona. Thinking is a process in reflection and decision making, but it becomes unhealthy when it traps you in one mind spot, unable to move forward with positive thoughts.
